The musicians were alleged to have ended their engagement at the start of November, but then an interview was published with Jesy in which she gushed about Jake, suggesting all was actually okay.
Now a new report in The Sun claims that interview was done six weeks ago and Jesy and Jake have actually parted ways.
Confused? Us too…
A source told The Sun: "Jesy and Jake have split up – there is nothing else to it. The engagement is over for the time being but it wouldn't be a huge surprise to see them patch things up in a few months."
Last week, an interview with Jesy was published by online outlet Idolator, in which she said of Jake: "We're very much in love and we'll do it when we feel the time is right."
Rumours of cracks in their relationship started when eagle eyed fans noticed Jesy had unfollowed Jake on Instagram. Jesy's rep declined to comment when approached by Reveal.
The pair had begun dating back in 2014 and the following year, Jake popped the question on stage at the Manchester Arena, where they had first met. He enlisted the help of pal Ed Sheeran who performed in the background as Jake proposed.
At the time, Jesy said: "I cannot believe what has just happened! The most surreal moment of my life and everyone that I love most was there to share it with us! I feel like the luckiest girl in the world rite now literally cannot stop crying! Future Mrs Roche."