Troy Frith and Oliver made their debut on Tuesday night (28 June) but, in a twist, they had just one day to woo the ladies and ensure their future in the villa.
Each guy was allowed to ask three women on a date: Troy opted for Kady, Tina and Liana, while Oliver chose Kady, Tina and Sophie.
Troy bonded best with Tina and the pair shared a smooch under the covers after he promised to spend the night with her.
Oliver liked Sophie best and told her: "I do feel we connect. I don't know if you do?" Sadly for Oliver, she replied: "It's so much pressure. I'm going to be honest, I feel it's too soon for me."
Once alone, Troy and Oliver had a chat about how they were getting on. Speaking about Tina, Troy said: "I don't feel stuff. I do like her. If another bird came in and she was all over me, I'd still go there."
Once the dates were over, Scott received a text asking the group to gather by the fire pit. The girls then received a text, asking them to each pick one of the lads to send packing.
Unfortunately for Oliver, all seven girls dumped him!
In the beach hut, Olivia later explained: "He didn't have a connection with anyone and wasn't fitting in. It was the only fair way to do it."
Before leaving the island, Oliver warned that Troy is a "player". He said: "One by one he will play the girls and that will cause a big problem."
Throughout the show, viewers were quick to share their initial thoughts on the newbies, and it seems they agreed with the islanders.
One said: "Troy is a massive player! But his teeth are amazing!!! #loveisland." Another added: "I think Adam & Oliver should match up as they're both dry as a bone!! #loveisland."
Love Island continues at 9pm on ITV2