The twosome were thought to have fallen for each other in the Australian jungle last year, after appearing together on I'm A Celebrity... Get Me Out Of Here! in November.
However, it seems their supposed budding romance hasn't made it into the New Year.
Despite fans championing the couple and their would-be relationship, a source told The Sun that apparently the spark just wasn't there.
"Things fizzled out towards the end of December," said the insider.
Even though Joey and Amy never confirmed that they were an item, they seemed to drop a number of hints that love was in the air after leaving the Aussie jungle and returning to British soil.
Not only did they attend the IAC wrap party together in December, Joey also introduced Amy to his TOWIE co-stars and referred to the blonde beauty as "my Ame" following their picture-perfect appearance at the British Comedy Awards.
And let's not forget those cosy Instagram photos they uploaded too!
Nevertheless, both stars look like they are happily moving on and hardly heartbroken over the supposed split.
In fact, Amy may have her eye on another Essex boy, as she was pictured cuddling up to TOWIE's Dan Osborne after they were both booked for a personal appearance at a club on the same night!
What do you think of Joey and Amy apparently calling it quits? Let us know below, as the best comment from across the website each week wins £50!
Got an iPad or iPhone? Reveal Mag has been especially designed to fit!