Nicky made waves when she stepped out at the glitzy red carpet event in the floor-sweeping, Aztec print number by Valentino, which was dripping in hundreds of glittering blue, red and orange beads.
The newlywed heiress looked every inch the ethereal princess as she scooped her honey-hued locks back into a Grecian bun with a classic centre parting and accessorised with a gleaming head garland adorned with leaves and oh-so-pretty blooms.
But as she sashayed down the star-studded red carpet, Nicky came face to face with fashion designer Tommy Hilfiger's wife, Dee Ocleppo, who had cherry picked the same frock from her overflowing wardrobe of glitzy gowns.
What are the chances?
Dee hid the dress' charming scoop neckline and wore her locks down, teaming the one-piece with a silver clutch bag and a matching pair of sandals.
Obviously gorgeous - there's no doubt about it - but the chic additions to Nicky's outfit including the enviably sleek locks and jewel encrusted earrings swing our vote!
Thankfully, the fashionable pair didn't let the SDA (same dress alert, FYI) stop them from having a blast and they mingled with on-screen stars including Bruce Willis, Kiera Knightly and Olivia Palermo at the Big Apple event before making a beeline for the champagne studded dinner table.
For exclusive competitions and amazing prizes visit Reveal's Facebook page NOW!