So we were surprised to spot her suffering a major fashion fail while promoting her new SJP shoe collection at Nordstrom in Miami this weekend (8 March).
While we loved Sarah's pretty red lace Saint Laurent frock, we weren't too taken by the rest of her peculiar ensemble.
The actress cast aside her usual fashion icon status in a questionable pair of sheer grey footless tights, complete with stirrups. Yikes!
She also chose to wear a white shirt by Wolford underneath her dress, which featured loose three-quarter length sleeves.
For jewellery the starlet tucked a string of pearls into her frock, adding an odd gold necklace plus a few chunky rings.
And to complete her strange get-up, the designer sported the Carrie T-strap Pumps from her own SJP collection (of course), which are on sale for a whopping £224.53.
We like the heels Sarah, but please, never pair them with those awful tights again!
What do you think of Sarah's outfit? Let us know by commenting below as the best comment across the site each week wins £50!
Got an iPad or iPhone? Reveal Mag is specially designed to fit!